Wildlife Angel
  • HOME
  • The NGO
    • EDITORIAL
    • THREAT OF POACHING
    • THE TEAM
  • OPERATIONS
  • MEDIAS
  • BLOG
  • CONTACT
  • DONATE
  • Français
  • HOME
  • The NGO
    • EDITORIAL
    • THREAT OF POACHING
    • THE TEAM
  • OPERATIONS
  • MEDIAS
  • BLOG
  • CONTACT
  • DONATE
  • Français
18 March 2016 In Poaching, Wildlife

Two Italian citizens killed during an anti-poaching operation

chasseurs-italiens-Wildlifeangel-2016

An anti-poaching operation that turned bad

An Italian hunting guide, Claudio Chiarelli, on the right of the picture, and his son Max were shot dead in the Mana Pools National Park in northeastern Zimbabwe. Participating in a joint operation with an anti-poaching unit of the park, they were mistaken for poachers by another unit patrolling the area.

The two Italian citizens naturalized Zimbabweans aged 65 and 28 years old were appreciated in the hunting industry in Zimbabwe. As many individuals living in the country, they used to help anti-poaching activities by providing logistical support to the operations. That day, Sunday, March 13, 2016, they were using their Toyota land cruiser vehicle to help a patrol.

The incident has created many waves in the community to which they belonged, and some questions remain unanswered today.

The General Director of the Zimbabwe Parks and Wildlife Management Authority said that the two Italians were killed by the Rangers from another unit than the one they were accompanying.

 

What happened

A team of rangers specialized in anti-poaching activities follows for several days a fresh track of poachers. The same day, they hear gunshots in an area frequented by elephants, near the banks of the Zambezi. They go on the track and notice some worrying movements nearby. They hear voices, lie in wait and break into a place where they surprise individuals near a vehicle. They immediately opened fire on the group convinced that they are poachers. It is only after the shooting that they find elements of another anti-poaching unit that actually accompanied the two men killed.

Manapools-Wildlifeangel-2016

The two rangers responsible of the shots and therefore of the death of the two Italian citizens were arrested by the police and interviewed in order to understand what really happened on this Sunday afternoon, in the heart of the Zimbabwean bush. They are likely to be charged with murder.
The journalists who lead the investigation ensure that the anti-poaching troops in recent months are on red alert because they faced a very big pressure since the death of the lion Cecil, very much publicized, and the elephant massacres that followed.
What are the lessons to be learned?

At this stage of the ongoing investigation, it is very difficult to identify and confirm any explanation of this tragic accident. The fact remains that two hypotheses are being circulated in the areas concerned by this case.First hypothesis, the most likely in my opinion. This is truly an accident, a mistake made by the rangers and this should not surprise anyone. For years I raise awareness about the necessary training of anti-poaching forces of different countries concerned. First, my speech emphasizes on the lack of preparedness of the units, their poor organization, management and operational expertise in the field. The staff should be trained to understand the field realities, of course, the threat that has changed and that is increasingly violent, we agree. But the focus must also be placed on their weapon control and their reactions to the touch.
Unfortunately, this case, if it is obviously an accident, reflects perfectly the lack of control of the staff’ reactions when they are in contact with danger. In our training on handling weapons and firing rules, we insist particularly on one point:
“Be sure of the target and its environment. ”
Obviously, this rule was not applied in such a case!
The explanation for this regrettable act lies in the lack of skills and training of rangers, which is what Wildlife Angel denounces since the beginning.
Second hypothesis, more complex to understand but that some people aware of the case believe credible. Claudio Chiarelli and his son were both professional hunters known in the country. Their company used to organize annual tourism and hunting safaris for their European customers. In 2006, there was talk of Mario Chiarelli because he had lost, during a hunting safari, an Italian customer trampled and killed by an elephant. However, since the case of Cecil the lion and the American dentist who benefited from the complicity of his Zimbabwean hunting guide, the relationship between the professional hunting guides and anti-poaching units are a little bit tense. Should we see a case of revenge or settling scores on the ivory war background?
two rangers responsible of the shots and therefore of the death of the two Italian citizens were arrested by the police and interviewed in order to understand what really happened on this Sunday afternoon, in the heart of the Zimbabwean bush. They are likely to be charged with murder.

The journalists who lead the investigation ensure that the anti-poaching troops in recent months are on red alert because they faced a very big pressure since the death of the lion Cecil, very much publicized, and the elephant massacres that followed.

 

What are the lessons to be learned?

At this stage of the ongoing investigation, it is very difficult to identify and confirm any explanation of this tragic accident. The fact remains that two hypotheses are being circulated in the areas concerned by this case.

First hypothesis, the most likely in my opinion. This is truly an accident, a mistake made by the rangers and this should not surprise anyone. For years I raise awareness about the necessary training of anti-poaching forces of different countries concerned. First, my speech emphasizes on the lack of preparedness of the units, their poor organization, management and operational expertise in the field. The staff should be trained to understand the field realities, of course, the threat that has changed and that is increasingly violent, we agree. But the focus must also be placed on their weapon control and their reactions to the touch.

Unfortunately, this case, if it is obviously an accident, reflects perfectly the lack of control of the staff’ reactions when they are in contact with danger. In our training on handling weapons and firing rules, we insist particularly on one point:

“Be sure of the target and its environment. ”

Obviously, this rule was not applied in such a case!

The explanation for this regrettable act lies in the lack of skills and training of rangers, which is what Wildlife Angel denounces since the beginning.

Second hypothesis, more complex to understand but that some people aware of the case believe credible. Claudio Chiarelli and his son were both professional hunters known in the country. Their company used to organize annual tourism and hunting safaris for their European customers. In 2006, there was talk of Mario Chiarelli because he had lost, during a hunting safari, an Italian customer trampled and killed by an elephant. However, since the case of Cecil the lion and the American dentist who benefited from the complicity of his Zimbabwean hunting guide, the relationship between the professional hunting guides and anti-poaching units are a little bit tense. Should we see a case of revenge or settling scores on the ivory war background?

Facebooklinkedinmail

Related Articles

  • parc-national-etosha-namibie
    What Model for Wildlife Conservation in Africa: private reserve, conservancy, national park?
  • African-Wildlife
    [Infographic] Africa's Wildlife in Danger

FACEBOOK

SEARCHING

CATEGORIES

  • About the NGO (4)
  • News (3)
  • Poaching (17)
  • Technology (2)
  • Wildlife (24)

ARCHIVES

  • January 2019 (1)
  • December 2018 (2)
  • June 2018 (1)
  • April 2017 (1)
  • January 2017 (2)
  • December 2016 (2)
  • June 2016 (2)
  • April 2016 (3)
  • March 2016 (3)
  • February 2016 (3)
  • January 2016 (5)
  • December 2015 (2)
  • May 2015 (4)

RSS NEWS FROM SOUTHERN AFRICA

  • Malawi: Kabwila - Malawi Must Lead, Not Lag, in Global Ai Revolution 27 June 2025
    [Nyasa Times] Minister of Higher Education, Hon. Dr. Jessie Kabwila, has hailed the 3rd UNESCO Global Forum on the Ethics of Artificial Intelligence as a landmark opportunity for Malawi to rise as a regional thought leader in ethical AI governance.
  • Lesotho: Gvt Lauds WFP's Fight for Food Security in Lesotho 27 June 2025
    [Lesotho Times] ...As agency launches second Country Strategic Plan
  • Lesotho: Justice Deferred Is Justice Denied 27 June 2025
    [Lesotho Times] IN an unprecedented development that has left scores of litigants grappling with a profound sense of betrayal, Lesotho's judiciary has announced a sweeping directive ordering a restart of numerous cases previously heard by retired Justice Tšeliso Monapathi and former Justice Keketso Moahloli.
  • South Africa: Government Identifies 59 Biodiversity Projects to Unlock Green Finance 27 June 2025
    [SAnews.gov.za] Government has identified 59 bankable biodiversity projects that are expected to generate at least $450,000 in green finance, Minister of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment, Dr Dion George announced during the department's budget vote speech in Parliament on Friday.
  • South Africa: SA Ratifies Landmark Women and Youth Protocol for Inclusive Trade 27 June 2025
    [SAnews.gov.za] South Africa has taken a significant step in fostering inclusive growth by officially ratified the Protocol Women and Youth in Trade under the African Continental Free Trade Area.

Copyright 2019 - Wildlife Angel : Plan de site - Mentions légales